5 Wellness Strategies that Don’t Work (and 5 that Do)

lunchCreative Commons License Gideon via Compfight

Strategies that don’t work:

1.  Diet – Diets in and of themselves rarely work and cannot be sustained indefinitely.  The longer someone is on a diet, the harder it gets.  Dieters tend to stretch their willpower too far and eventually end up caving in to temptation usually ending up right back where they started.

2.  Visualize Success – One strategy that has been made popular by self-help books such as “The Secret” is to accomplish our goals simply by imagining them as reality.  The problem with this strategy is that visualization only works insomuch as it inspires confidence and action that propel the person to do what is needed.  If people choose visualization in lieu of action, they are doomed for failure.

3.  Overcome Obstacles – Some people, rather than keeping their eye on the goal, they focus on the challenges that are in their way.  Overcoming the obstacles can seem like an important way to reach a goal but it can also be demotivating.  Obstacles can easily become excuses that help to justify our inability to make headway.

4.  Shortcuts – If something sounds too good to be true it probably is.  The miracle pill or surgery that is promised to bring you instant health and happiness usually won’t.  Most shortcut solutions are designed to change the superficial symptoms without addressing the underlying problems.  Or they simply “move the boo-boo” from one place to another.  These strategies also lure us away from doing the hard work that true wellness requires.

5.  Contemplation – Most people spend a lot more time planning their wellness strategies than they do actually executing them.  Reading about wellness is not a strategy.  Talking about wellness is not a strategy.  Hope is not a strategy.  Only when contemplation turns into action do we see results (see Prochaska’s stages of change.)

Two female joggers on foggy Morro Strand State BeachCreative Commons License Mike Baird via Compfight

Strategies that do work:

1.  Exercise – Unlike diet, exercise gets easier with practice.  The more people exercise, the more likely it becomes a sustainable part of their lifestyle.  Also, unlike dieting, exercise simultaneously boosts mood and psychological wellbeing while improving physical fitness.

2.  Future Time Perspective – Visualization in and of itself doesn’t work, but thinking about your future can keep you more focused on doing what you need to do in the present.  What is willpower, after all, but the ability to delay immediate gratification in order to achieve long term goals.  Thinking about the future outcomes you wish to achieve can motivate and inspire you to make the sacrifices necessary in the short term. (See Zimbardo’s “The Time Paradox.”)

3.  Mental Contrasting – Effective goal accomplishment comes when you can simultaneously hold the future vision of success in mind while contrasting it against the obstacles that need to be overcome.  The future vision of the goal provides the motivation, while the awareness of the obstacles helps to prepare you to take appropriate action when they inevitably pop up.  Try a mental contrasting exercise here.

4.  Mindfulness – A mindfulness practice helps develop skills that shift our attention to where we want it to go, rather than wherever it gets pulled.  Mindful eating, for example, is more effective than dieting for developing healthy habits.

5.  Be Social Wellness is contagious.  (So is obesity.)  Both positive and negative health habits tend to spread through social networks.  So connect with people that have the kind of health you would like to have.  Working out with a friend, or sharing your progress on wellness goals via social media channels can both help motivate you to achieve your goals.

What works for you?

References and recommended reading:

Halvorson, H. G. (2010). Succeed: How We Can Reach Our Goals. Hudson Street Press.

Miller, C. A. & Frisch, M. B. (2011). Creating Your Best Life: The Ultimate Life List Guide. Sterling.

, ,

4 Responses to 5 Wellness Strategies that Don’t Work (and 5 that Do)

  1. tiggy August 6, 2013 at 3:15 pm #

    Jeremy,

    I’d say sleep, nutrition and meditation (as distinct from mindfulness) probably work.

    I’d say spa is a shortcut and like diets doesn’t work in the long term

    Thoughts????

  2. Rob August 6, 2013 at 5:35 pm #

    What a load of rubbish, you condemn a strategy i.e visualistion and then say it works if it inspires action, and who plans a shortcut strategy? Come on! You could have given this article more thought!

  3. Jeremy McCarthy August 12, 2013 at 9:18 am #

    Hi “tiggy”, Unlike the other wellness strategies you mention, spa is only a place, so it depends what you do when you are there. But if you agree that sleep and meditation are effective than I would think you would appreciate having a place you can go to experience silence, separation from technology, etc. My point about diet is that it is self-defeating (the more you diet the less motivation/capacity you have to diet, etc.) as opposed to exercise, which is self-fulfilling (the more you exercise, the more more motivation/capacity you have to exercise, etc.) I would say spa is more like exercise in this case since in my experience, the more people go to spas the more they appreciate the benefit of it and are inspired to go.

  4. tiiggy August 13, 2013 at 5:00 am #

    spa is like exercise??

    me thinks you spin just a little

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes